I'm generally skeptical of travel writers' advice on Brooklyn, because they tend to treat the borough as a single organism, rather than a set of neighborhoods best grasped in clusters, thanks to walkable proximity or easy public transit access.

(I'm omitting taxi/Uber/Lyft, though I know that's a "normal" choice for many visitors because, well, I think 20-30 minutes in Brooklyn traffic is a waste of time and money.)

So when I saw 10 best Brooklyn hotels for views, luxury and boutique stays, from The Independent in London, I was taken aback by the writer's certainty. 

As I've suggested on my Picking a Hotel in Brooklyn page, the threshold question for me is LOCATION--proximity to walkable attractions, restaurants, shops, and parks, as well as public transit.

So this article, by failing to truly address that key question, falls short.

Location questions

It says the location depends on what you want, so Williamsburg is great for ""a vibrant nightlife scene with bars, trendy restaurants and street art." Actually, there's not much street art left, but Williamsburg offers easy L train access to Brooklyn's street art capital, Bushwick.

Though five (!) of the ten hotels listed were in Williamsburg, you shouldn't choose that neighborhood unless your focus is North Brooklyn, not "Brooklyn." It does not offer the access to Brooklyn's great walkable "brownstone" neighborhoods, while hotels in Downtown Brooklyn--some better than others--and even Gowanus do so. (You can make a quick trip to DUMBO by ferry.)

"For a more relaxed vibe without compromising on a creative culture," the article states, "consider Greenpoint, home to a lively food and drink scene, waterfront access and a break from the chaos of Manhattan."

Greenpoint's a terrific neighborhood, but it's very far from most of Brooklyn, with no public transit access--and a long drive--to key attractions like Prospect Park, the Brooklyn Botanic Garden, and the Brooklyn Museum. One of the two hotels they recommend is at the northern tip of Greenpoint, far from even some attractions in the neighborhood.

"And for iconic views of the skyline and Brooklyn Bridge, DUMBO is hard to beat," the article states. "As well as offering easy access to Brooklyn Bridge Park, you can also find galleries and boutiques to browse."

But DUMBO is a must-see for nearly every visitor to Brooklyn, and there's only one hotel there, the One Hotel Brooklyn Bridge. So unless you want to pay for the most expensive hotel in Brooklyn, why not figure out other ways to get there? 

Hint: DUMBO, and even the Brooklyn Museum, may be an easier trip from some hotels in Manhattan than in Brooklyn.

Consider the "at a glance" list at the top of the article.

• Best hotel for families: Box House Hotel
• Best hotel with a view: 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge
• Best hotel with a swimming pool: Arlo Williamsburg hotel
• Best luxury hotel: The William Vale hotel
• Best boutique hotel: Wythe Hotel

Putting aside the failure to address location, the list still fails.

Three of the five "best" hotels are within two blocks of each other: the Arlo Williamsburg, The William Vale, and the Wythe Hotel. (Another hotel on the list, The Hoxton, is also within that two-block area.)

More quibbles
Then it's easy to quibble with the distinctions. While I haven't tested what hotels have the best swimming pool, but I can confidently say that the best hotel with swimming pool is the 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge, as suggested by its cost: more than three times that of the Arlo.

Is the 1 Hotel, clearly the most luxurious hotel in Brooklyn, the best hotel with a view? Yes, but is it the "best view"? The ten-story hotel offers great views of Lower Manhattan and the financial district. But hotels in Williamsburg like the 22-story William Vale, have great views of midtown Manhattan and rooftop bars with a much bigger vista.

Is the William Vale the best luxury hotel? Well, the 1 Hotel costs 72% more, so maybe that's the hint.

Is the Wythe Hotel the best boutique hotel? Probably, but only if you're planning to focus on Williamsburg. 

Is the Box House Hotel the best hotel for families? Well, it does offer larger rooms.

But the claim that it has a "fantastic location among restaurants, coffee shops, art galleries, and boutiques" is ridiculous. It's at the northern tip of Greenpoint, far from even some of the great attractions of north Brooklyn, like McGolrick Park in Greenpoint and Domino Park in Williamsburg, and a long way from, the rest of Brooklyn.

Heck, the Box House Hotel actually offers good access to Long Island City in Queens, which has museums like MOMA PS 1 and a terrific waterfront park. There's also new waterfront open space in Greenpoint, walkable from the hotel.

For Williamsburg, the question is price. When I tested bookings, The Penny Williamsburg--not mentioned in the article--was less expensive than the cluster of hotels near the water, which makes sense, because, well, it's next to a highway and farther from the neighborhood's attractions. The Pod Hotel Brooklyn, unmentioned in the article, is better located, and less expensive, but the spaces are small, as the name suggests.

Of the hotels listed, only the EVEN Hotel and the Ace Hotel Brooklyn are in Downtown Brooklyn, my recommended location. They both offer good access to the Barclays Center and the Brooklyn Academy of Music, as well as the DeKalb Market Hall food court and the classic deli-diner Junior's.

But they don't offer quite as good access to neighborhood Brooklyn, such as Cobble Hill and Brooklyn Heights, than some Downtown Brooklyn hotels a bit to the west. (This is a question of degree, not a deal-breaker.) That said, Fort Greene, just past the Brooklyn Academy of Music, is within walking distance of the EVEN and the Ace, at least if you cross the barrier of Flatbush Avenue.

There are a lot more hotels in Downtown Brooklyn that weren't mentioned. If you want to see "Brooklyn," it offers a lot of options. Also, if you want to go to Coney Island, a must-visit in warmer months, Downtown Brooklyn offers a lot better access than does North Brooklyn.

A lot of people watch travel vlogs to try to get a quick impression of a destination. Heck, I do too. But it's always wise to supplement them with more focused information, for example from guidebooks and recently reported travel articles.

Even those have their flaws and limitations, which is why--self-serving plug here--it can be valuable to hire a guide.

Let me dissect the immense flaws in a vlog modestly titled "48 Hours in BROOKLYN 🇺🇸 First time in New York's COOLEST Borough!" from Australian Phoebe Lee, whose vlog has 267,000 subscribers. She goes everywhere--Rome, South Africa, Thailand!--which is how, I suppose, she builds subscribers.

A superficial visit
​
But that also makes it more likely her visits and reports will be superficial, as her Brooklyn video confirms. Despite the "COOLEST" claim, the things that make Brooklyn "coolest" or even very attractive were not so visible.

Lee opens up by wondering "if it was worth coming out here to spend an extra couple of nights or not. I really don't know if there's going to be enough to see and do and eat ." Clearly, she didn't do much research.

Sure, people have to parcel out their time, but there's more than enough for weeks of visiting.

Unsurprisingly, she assumes that most first-time visitors would come to Brooklyn as part of their trip to Manhattan, checking off the bucket-list requirement of walking the Brooklyn Bridge. 

Preconceived ideas

Lee acknowledges "preconceived ideas. For me, I feel like Brooklyn is going to be hipsters. For some reason, I think I'm going to see a lot of pickles and a lot of artisanal breads and such. My mom is completely freaking out. She thinks it's very unsafe and when I asked her why she says because the TV show she watches a lot of the crimes happen in Brooklyn."

Well, both are true about "Brooklyn," which is so vast it includes everything.

Given that Lee spent her time in a tiny portion of Brooklyn, she was closer to the artisanal stuff, though a little research would've shown that independent businesses tend to congregate in gentrifying areas, not ones that have gentrified solidly.

Her visit

She has a pleasant coffee and snack at Poppy's--not Poppies--in Brooklyn Heights, which she likes a lot. However, it's not clear how she got there--subway? walk?--as it's not so close to the hotel she later discloses. (Remember, logistics are important.)

Then she's walking on the Brooklyn Bridge, not immediately proximate, and enjoys the views. Worth noting how long it took, however. She acknowledges she ignored the advice to come early, and now it's crowded.

Lee goes to the famous DUMBO photo spot, at Washington Street and Water Street, but it's very crowded. (She doesn't explain why it's famous or, as I tell my clients, what else is nearby, including what I consider a better photo.) 

She goes to "Pebble Beach" for the views, but doesn't learn anything about the history of Brooklyn Bridge Park. She goes to Time Out NY Market but offers nothing about the history of the building.

Lee finds a pickle spot but nothing she wanted to eat. Hm, I would've advised her to go to the market's rooftop annex, with another, smaller set of vendors, and great views. 

About pizza

She winds up nearby at Juliana's Pizza, where she loves her marinara pie but somehow relies on a source she read regarding "the difference between Brooklyn and New York Pizza," that "Brooklyn tends to have a crispy dough throughout it should crack when you fold the slice whereas the classic New York slice still has the crispy edge but a softer dough underneath the cheese so it bends when you fold it."

What? Did that come from here? Does she really think the pizza changes magically once you cross the bridge, and that Brooklyn is not part of New York? 

The real distinction is between a coal-fired oven place, like Juliana's, which sell whole pies only, and standard slice shops, which use gas ovens. At least she missed the lines, which means she went at an off-hour.

More in DUMBO

She then goes to Pier 1, for waterfront views, but ignores the story of Brooklyn Bridge Park or the hotel nearby. It's less crowded. (Actually, it's still one of the more crowded places.) She ignores several food options.. 

Lee gets to see the Statue of Liberty, since she doesn't want to make a day trip to go there. (I agree, but, pro tip here: take the free Staten Island Ferry.)

On the basis of this rather limited sample, she concludes that Brooklyn is a "lot more chill" than Manhattan.  

Visiting a neighborhood

Then she walks around Brooklyn Heights to talk about "Brooklyn Brownstones," and "they do not disappoint." However, Brooklyn Heights is not the place you go for brownstone-clad houses because that era came later. (Go to Park Slope or Bed-Stuy for the best.) 

It has a relatively small number of brownstones, but other impressive buildings. She somehow omits the Brooklyn Heights promenade and the views from there. 

Toward Downtown Brooklyn

Lee gets to Borough Hall and the Fulton Mall--apparently she's missed some iconic buildings in Brooklyn Heights, as well as its improved Montague Street shopping district and then provides her "hotel tour" of the Aloft.

"I don't know if this is a good location," she says, which could be a code for "I don't see many trendy cafes" or "I see a lot of working-class people of color."

Downtown Brooklyn is a fine location--it's one of the few places with many hotels, thanks to zoning, and even if there are fewer trendier businesses (there are some) it offers great access to transit and other nearby neighborhoods. 

"I'm just not sure walking around here that this neighborhood is my vibe," she says. "I prefer to be in more of a local feeling spot so I'm wondering if over the next few days I'm actually going to uncover a place that I wish I had have stayed." 

Duh, there aren't a lot of options for perfection here. Stay in Greenpoint? You're in the middle of nowhere. Stay in Williamsburg? Most hotels are pricey.

Retracing her steps

On her second day, Lee returns early the Brooklyn Bridge--not a short walk from the Aloft--and but says that, despite the noise from commuting vehicles, it was worth it, to avoid the other tourists.

She returns to the Washington Street photo op, now devoid of tourists, but doesn't think to go elsewhere in DUMBO beyond Butler, a "cute little spot" for breakfast.

To Williamsburg

Lee then takes a vehicle to Williamsburg--I would've advised taking the East River Ferry--which she calls "a real artsy kind of area," a description that applies only if she had a time machine to go back 20+ years. (Note: you can get to Williamsburg more easily on public transit from Manhattan than from DUMBO.)

"It's extremely trendy and apparently the hipster capital of Brooklyn," she says. "I don't know if it's just me. I'm not feeling it."

Well, the hipsters visit, but Williamsburg hasn't been the hipster capital for a while. The trendy shopping streets now resemble SoHo, but Williamsburg is more than that--it's large enough that it has a Hispanic area, a Hasidic area, and the gentrified part has interesting stuff.

It's not quite clear where she went beyond Bedford Avenue. "Something is just putting me on edge," she says. Hm, maybe because it's commodified, and she didn't know where to go.

So she decides to get something to eat and it's a visit to the chain Whole Foods! This is clearly for an international audience, but, since you can get Whole Foods in any major city, any visit to Williamsburg requires finding a local spot.

Logistics, logistics

Lee then acknowledges that "we have had a little bit of a fail," as she brought the food back to her hotel--in Downtown Brooklyn, which means she didn't vlog the vehicle ride back subway--hoping for access to a roof, but didn't get it. If she knew that, she says, "I would have either gone to Domino Park or I would have gone down to Dumbo."

Wow. Maybe she should've gotten a drink on the roof of a Williamsburg hotel, then gotten takeout (not from Whole Foods) and taken it to Domino Park.

Reflections and conclusion

When she checked in, Lee confesses, "I was really worried about the location of the hotel"--why? safety, street people, not near "fun" stuff"--"but after spending the last couple of days here downtown or DUMBO are definitely where you want to stay."

Um, there's only one hotel in DUMBO, the One Hotel, and it's great, but it's also very expensive. Downtown Brooklyn has tons of hotels, thanks to zoning, but I'd advise picking one that gives you the closest access to a charming residential neighborhood. (Or stay in Gowanus.)

From the Aloft, Lee did have access to interesting things in a different direction, first DeKalb Market, a great food hall, the iconic Brooklyn deli-diner Junior's, and then the neighborhood of Fort Greene, capital of Brooklyn's performing arts cultural scene. All were absent from her radar.

"I think, looking back on it. I don't think I needed two nights here," she concludes. Well, sure, if all she's going to do is re-do Day 1, then sure. But she ignored so much in Brooklyn.

Oddly, she advises that people stay in Brooklyn to save "and then just go and do all of your adventures in Manhattan every day." However, should she have had a do-over, "I would just come out to Brooklyn for the day. I think that would be more than enough."

That's a bit of a fail. Though most people in the comments simply praise her, the most upvoted comments gently suggests that, well, she could've seen a bit more... Cobble Hill and Carroll Gardens, Park Slope and Prospect Park, the Brooklyn Museum and the Brooklyn Botanic Garden. There's so much more.

Over the years, I've been known to recommend various restaurants, cafes, pizzerias, ice cream shops, and bakeries to visitors. Sometimes even hotels.

Such advice is all based on my experience as a tour guide since 2000 and a New York City resident far longer. I don't get any benefit from such advice.

I now have a recommendation that could benefit both you and me. If you download the app InKind and join (it's free), you'll get $25 off a $50 (or more) tab at hundreds of restaurants in New York and many other cities. (I'll get a credit once you use it.)
Here's the link. 
How it works

You'll get other benefits while using it. When you pay your bill with InKind (linked to a credit card), you'll get 20% back in InKind credit, which then accumulates in a Wallet, thus helping you pay future bills.

You can also buy credit at a discount.

Your tip and tax are paid separately, and the tip, of course, is calculated on the full bill.

You may get random, short-term offers from InKind, like the $25 credit I recently got for a Restaurant Week meal in New York, or a credit for a particular restaurant. (Be careful to activate special deals, and choose that deal rather than the standard 20% cash back when paying the bill.)

(What's the catch? Well, there's an unusual business model, as I'll explain below.)

The case for InKind

Why do I recommend InKind? I learned about it not when seeking a bargain but when looking into Mercado Little Spain, from the famed chef Jose Andres.

Now I use it regularly.

Some favorites include the cafe/bakery Winner, in Park Slope; the local cafe/bakery chain Maman (also in DC and a few other cities); the Ethiopian restaurant Ras Plant Based, in Crown Heights; the ice cream chain Van Leeuwen; the Middle Eastern counter-serve spot Spice Brothers in the East Village, and the Thai restaurant Kru in Williamsburg.

The coupon or discount has also prompted me to try some establishments that might seem pricey, like the famed Superiority Burger in the East Village, or the revamped Montague Diner in Brooklyn Heights. With the discount, they were very good values.

Heck, stellar splurge restaurants like the Union Square Cafe and Gramercy Tavern are on InKind!

Behind the business

The restaurant business is a notoriously tough one, given the enormous variables of food costs, staff costs, weather, and seasonal traffic, plus low margins.

InKind's business model, as this article explains, departs from traditional restaurant financing modes, offering upfront cash in exchange for twice as much value in restaurant credit, which it will then sell back to diners--us--at a roughly 25% overall discount.

InKind makes money on the spread, but only as long as the restaurant is successful, so the company--unlike, say, a bank or loan shark that could repossess an asset--has an incentive to first choose quality establishments and then encourage more people to go to them. 

To quote InKind: "Restaurants receive funding at the lowest cost of capital available, plus marketing support that drives more customer visits. Consumers receive monetary bonuses to spend at inKind partner restaurants plus additional dining perks. It's a win-win model for operators and consumers."

There hasn't been much journalism about InKind, so it's hard to know how much restaurant operators like it. In this Reddit thread, one owner was wary of the 50% discount, given margins below 10% in the restaurant business.

Among the responses: the InKind credit may not be fully redeemed; the delay in redemption lowers the discount rate, and the app may drive more customers, all tipping on the full bill, thus rewarding employees.

Give it a try and let me know what you think!

Condé Nast Traveler recently published A Local's Guide to Bed-Stuy, Brooklyn and How to Spend a Perfect Day in Williamsburg, Brooklyn.

Those are signs that, beyond "Brooklyn"--a huge and amorphous category--as a destination, people are targeting specific neighborhoods. That's a good idea, as I always advise to approach exploration in adjacencies.

So what do I think of the articles?

(Let's put aside the fact that the first article--at least as initially published--makes a basic geographical error, classifying establishments in the western part of Bed-Stuy, closer to Classon Avenue, as "East Bed-Stuy." C'mon, Fan Fan Doughnuts is almost in Clinton Hill, and there's a lot more of a backstory to the shop and the location.)

Well, they're all about consumption--eating, drinking, and shopping--and to a lesser degree, experiences, such as nightclubs. Those are surely part of most visitors' itineraries, so these lists are useful, especially for younger travelers.

However, a lot is missing, some of which I try to convey on my walking tours: a larger sense of neighborhood evolution; key buildings and architecture, including houses, schools, and places of worship; local politics; civic and community crusades; social services; public murals; and, of course, real estate development.

Each neighborhood is a rich "text" to read. There's much to see in between the locations of consumption, and so many stories along the way.

The Brooklyn Chamber of Commerce (of which I was once a member) has created a new travel guide, VisitBrooklyn.NYC.

Overall, it has some useful elements, notably event listings, but it's not a good single guide for visiting Brooklyn. Is there one? Not really. The one Fodor's guide is out of print. Some general NYC guides at least hit some highlights.

For hotel and restaurant reviews, it's better to go to specialized sites like TripAdvisor, Yelp, Eater, and The Infatuation (the latter two only for food), or even just Google reviews.

Travel articles, like the New York Times's "36 Hours in Brooklyn," are somewhat useful, since they've been vetted, though--as I wrote--they typically send visitors skittering around Brooklyn rather than pursuing nearby neighborhoods and attractions.

Outsourced to AI?

Some the new guide's content is so bland, without editing or fact-checking, I suspect it was produced by an artificial intelligence program, with little follow-up.

Consider the screenshot above left, regarding attractions in Brooklyn Heights. It cites an aggregate review score and a total number of reviews, neither of which are referenced with a link.

An excerpt regarding the Brooklyn Heights Promenade: "At the edge of Brooklyn Heights, overlooking the bustling metropolis of New York City, lies the Brooklyn Heights Promenade. A haven of tranquility amidst the urban landscape, this elevated walkway offers visitors a respite from the chaos below."

From Google Gemini: "It provides a peaceful escape from the city's hustle and bustle, acting as a 'haven of tranquility' amidst the urban landscape, according to user reviews on Google Maps." Bing.

Overview

VisitBrooklyn.NYC It contains event listings (Now in Bklyn), mini-profiles of Neighborhoods, Eat and Drink, Where to Stay, Things to Do, Shop Brooklyn Made, and Visitor information.

The latter offers  basic information on transportation, fast facts, useful phone numbers, and info on alcohol, smoking, and cannabis. That doesn't much help people figure out what they should be exploring.

Oddly enough, no tour guides or companies are listed, though I'm sure some are Chamber members.

There's a decent list of rooftop bars and the Celebrate Brooklyn concert lineup. The Museums & Galleries page unwisely places the Brooklyn Museum at par with smaller, infrequently open neighborhood galleries and ignores the New York Transit Museum, the Brooklyn Children's Museum, Weeksville Heritage Center, and the Museum of Food and Drink.

The guide offers a few selective trip planners, such as a decent one for Brighton Beach. Listings for Brooklyn's live theaters are useful, but the Brooklyn Academy of Music (BAM) calendar ends June 8.

Am I being too tough on a fledgling effort? Well, it's hard to do this right! (The website launched, as far as I can tell, very recently, and new Instagram content began in March.)

Neighborhoods

The section on neighborhoods needs some editing, for example mixing up Williamsburg and East Williamsburg, both of which get credit for "a mix of historic buildings, modern developments, and waterfront parks."

Um, only Williamsburg has waterfront parks. Also, the claim that East Williamsburg has "a historic Jewish community" rather applies only to Williamsburg.

The listing for Bedford-Stuyvesant offers a few highlights, but doesn't explain how the neighborhood's vast and deserves some guidance on how to approach it.

The listing for DUMBO, Brooklyn's most touristed neighborhood, offers a bland description--"a trendy neighborhood known for its stunning waterfront views and converted industrial buildings"--with no guidance for specific spots.

The listing for Brooklyn Heights does mention a few attractions, but wrongly suggests that Montague Street leads to Brooklyn Bridge Park and recommends checking out "Pilot, a historic 1924 schooner," which is currently closed..

Other listings are pablum, as if scraped from a real-estate website, rather than oriented toward visitors. Park Slope "is a family-friendly neighborhood known for its historic brownstones and vibrant community," with "a mix of local shops, cafes, and restaurants, along with several parks and playgrounds." Um, hello: Prospect Park?

Kensington "is a diverse and family-friendly neighborhood with a mix of residential housing and local businesses. The area is known for its tree-lined streets, parks, and community-oriented atmosphere." Um, hello: Little Bangladesh?

Things to do

It's not intuitive to find, but If you click from the main page on Things to Do and ignore the drop-down list, you get Things to do: Neighborhood. This can be useful--or not.

The Brooklyn Heights listing, excerpted in the screenshot above, does include the New York Transit Museum--actually in Downtown Brooklyn. However, if museums are places to visit on a rainy day, it should be listed on the Museums page.

The DUMBO listing includes Brooklyn Bridge Park, Jane’s Carousel, Empire Fulton Ferry State Park, A.I.R. Gallery, and St. Anne’s Warehouse. However, Empire Fulton Ferry State Park is now part of Brooklyn Bridge Park, and there's no mention of Time Out New York Market in Empire Stores, among the most visited attractions, or even the cliched photo opportunity at a key DUMBO intersection.

Bizarrely, the listing for Kensington includes mention of Tea Arts & Culture and The Legacy event space, neither of which have an address or website. (The former, I believe, operates floating public events, and the latter might be a Hasidic banquet hall in nearby Borough Park.)

What about food?

I took a quick look at the restaurant listings.

Why only five Thai restaurants in Brooklyn, especially when two--Ugly Baby and Thai Farm Kitchen, mistakenly termed Thai Farm Chicken!--are closed? I've been to five Thai places in Cobble Hill/Carroll Gardens alone!

(Note: Thai Farm Chicken, perhaps the result of an AI hallucination, now appears in AI search results, credited to a "Brooklyn travel guide.")

Why only nine pizzerias? Omitted are the DUMBO coal-oven favorites Juliana's and Grimaldi's, the legendary L&B Spumoni Gardens (in Gravesend and now DUMBO), and the eight places that led Grub Street to claim The Best Pizza in the World Can Be Found in One Square Mile of Williamsburg.

(Note to clients: I think Brooklyn's best slice joint is not in Williamsburg. I can direct you there or accompany you if a visit works logistically.)

Sources like Yelp, The Infatuation, and Eater would be far more useful.

What about hotels?

The hotels are purportedly listed by neighborhood, but that's a fuzzy, misleading exercise. Some hotels in Downtown Brooklyn are instead classified as being in Brooklyn Heights or Boerum Hill. (Here's my advice on hotels.)

Moreover, the listings clearly aren't vetted. One hotel claims to be "minutes" from the Barclays Center, which translates to "25 minutes by foot." Neither of the two "Coney Island" hotels are near the amusement district.

Despite the name, the "Comfort Inn Prospect Park" isn't near the park and thus shouldn't be classified as in the neighborhood "Prospect Park" (which, of course, isn't a neighborhood).

The promotional language obscures the fact that some hotels can be dilapidated or dangerous, at least according to TripAdvisor reviews. Always check!

Hello, visitors! Yes, it's OK to buy a generic "New York" t-shirt or hat or sweatshirt. But it's often glaring proof that you're a tourist.

The place to wear them is back home.

The more savvy thing to do is to buy a T-shirt from a local business or organization (not an illegal vendor of schlock). I like doing that support them.

Two great places to buy New York swag: CityStore, the official store of the City of New York, which is located in the Municipal Building near the entrance to the Brooklyn Bridge, and the New York City Transit Museum Store, with locations at Grand Central terminal, 2 Broadway in Lower Manhattan, and the museum itself in Downtown Brooklyn.

Both also offer the opportunity to purchase online. I got my "A" t-shirt, which refers to the highest grade restaurants can get after a Health Department inspection, at CityStore.

As a tour guide specializing in private, customizable tours of Brooklyn neighborhoods (plus a few in Queens and Manhattan), I meet many visitors who've already been to New York City--well, mostly Manhattan--multiple times.

But some don’t fully grasp a question in my client questionnaire: “On the day of the tour, where (address, or cross streets, or hotel) will you be leaving from, if you know?”

Despite an addendum urging them to be as specific as possible (though I don't want their apartment number!), I still get responses like “Midtown,” “Times Square,” or “Upper East Side.”

Then I ask them to be more specific. After all, given the multiple subway lines and transit options, only a specific location can help me estimate travel time and offer the best advice on where to meet me.

Where's "Times Square"?

For example, I often meet visitors near the York Street stop on the F train in DUMBO. If they’re in “Times Square” east of Seventh Avenue, I’ll advise them to get the F train along Sixth Avenue at either 42nd Street or 47-50th Street, depending on their specific location. (Yes, I know we locals would take the D or the B express if it comes first, then switch at West Fourth Street.)

But if they’re west of Seventh Avenue, I’ll advise taking the A, C, or E train along Eighth Avenue to West Fourth Street and then transferring downstairs to the F. See the screenshot at right, from this map.

Some clients, trying to be cooperative, say, “I’ll meet you wherever you want in Brooklyn” or “I’ll just Uber to meet you.”

I appreciate the sentiment, but I'd still like specifics! First, I’d like to be able to estimate their travel time, so I can better anticipate our meeting time.

More importantly, if I know where they’re starting, I might adjust the meeting spot, or the tour route, to take advantage of their travel options, whether by subway, bus, taxi/Uber, or even ferry.

I aim to help visitors make the most of their experience, and justify the premium paid for personal service. To do that, I need more information.

"It was only after World War II that Bed-Stuy became mostly black," according to Mapping the African-American Past, a project from Columbia University to bolster the New York State social studies curriculum. "This enabled the community to go to the polls in 1960 and elect Shirley Chisholm, the first black woman to serve in the U.S. Congress." (See screenshot below.)

Hold on. It's a lot more complicated, as I've learned during my research for my Bedford-Stuyvesant tour.

The sad fact is that a Black majority in Central Brooklyn, including adjacent Crown Heights, did not enable voters to elect Shirley Chisholm in 1960. At that point, Central Brooklyn was glaringly gerrymandered, allowing the perpetuation of five white incumbents, who each included a slice, but hardly made the locals' interests a priority.

Rather, Chisholm was elected in 1968, and only after a lawsuit under the federal Voting Rights Act, passed in 1965, forced a reapportionment to create the new 12th Congressional District. We should see her in two murals as we walk around the neighborhood.

Periodically I get clients who ask me for advice on choosing a hotel in Brooklyn (or for a visit to Brooklyn), or ask me what I think of their hotel choice. I respond with my candid opinion. (I don't get kickbacks!)

Obviously, you pay more for a nicer room in a better equipped hotel. Or you might have hotel points you want to deploy.

My main advice regards location, and access to nearby public transportation and proximity to shopping/restaurants, as well as access to other attractions in Brooklyn.

Sure, if you want to spend money on taxis/Ubers, that's fine, but New Yorkers typically rely on the subway or bus, and like to be able to walk to at least some restaurants and stores.

My advice can't guarantee you a great room or a true bargain. Please read reviews of any hotel to recognize what previous visitors liked and disliked.​ But I can help you plan to make the best use of your location.

Please recognize that simply lodging in Brooklyn does not position you to reach every attraction in Brooklyn. I once had clients who chose a nice hotel in Williamsburg, and planned to visit the Brooklyn Museum, twice. They had to take costly, and slow, Ubers, because there's no easy connection via public transportation.

Had they stayed in Downtown Brooklyn or Gowanus, it would have been much easier. A lot of places in Brooklyn are also easily accessible from hotels in Lower Manhattan, in the Financial District, given good subway access. Those may be relative bargains.

​

​The screenshot above is from this map I've created of hotels in Brooklyn. I think of hotels as located in three main clusters: Downtown Brooklyn (blue); Gowanus (dark maroon); and Williamsburg (green).

Downtown Brooklyn gives you access to transportation--both to Manhattan and deeper in Brooklyn (like Prospect Park and the Brooklyn Museum), as well as the key clusters of neighborhoods in Brownstone Brooklyn (as in my Brooklyn 101 and Brooklyn 202 tours), and many other neighborhoods in the borough.

Some hotels are better located than others. I often recommend the Nu Hotel, the southernmost, because it has the quickest access to charming tree-lined streets and good shopping/dining in the adjacent neighborhoods of Cobble Hill and Carroll Gardens. (But do read reviews about noise from construction nearby and check your room's location.) Also nearby: Hilton, Ace, Holiday Inn, Even.

The New York Marriott at the Brooklyn Bridge does offers good access to walk the bridge, but it's farther from neighborhood Brooklyn. Still, as the borough's largest hotel, it's always easy to get a ride from there.

Some hotels in Downtown Brooklyn, like the Tillary Hotel and the Hampton Inn Downtown Brooklyn, are closer to busy, noisy streets and farther from walkable neighborhoods, but that's probably reflected in the cost.

Note: DUMBO has Brooklyn's most luxurious and expensive hotel, the One Hotel Brooklyn Bridge (orange). It offers great access to the waterfront (including the ferry to Williamsburg and Greenpoint), but may not be well positioned for a long visit if you want to see other parts of Brooklyn, since it's not near the subway.

Gowanus is an industrial/commercial area with lower-cost and more basic hotels, but it offers relatively good access, by foot up a mild slope, to the residential neighborhood of Park Slope, with good shopping and dining, and, ultimately, Prospect Park. The R train is nearby. It's just a little more desolate at night. The neighborhoods of Carroll Gardens and Cobble Hill are walkable, at least by day, through a mixed industrial and construction zone, with some retail.
Note that some hotels in Gowanus, and in Sunset Park (not listed here) and Long Island City in Queens (ditto), have been converted, at least temporarily to shelters. So the Holiday Inn Express in Gowanus is not at this moment accepting guests.

Williamsburg is Brooklyn's hipster zone, with a cluster of hotels in the north, near McCarren Park and a nightlife zone, a few hotels near the Brooklyn-Queens Expressway (check reviews for noise), and one new hotel (the Moxy), along Bedford Avenue in the Southside.

Williamsburg, along with adjacent neighborhood Greenpoint, offer lots of things to do/see/eat, and Williamsburg, thanks to the L train, offers good access to neighborhoods in Manhattan along 14th Street (Union Square, East Village, West Village). 

Note the hotels I've marked in gray. The two close to Flushing Avenue are far from hipster Williamsburg but close to the Hasidic (Orthodox Jewish) section. The one on Broadway is not as remote, but still a long walk to most places visitors might want to see.

Also note three Greenpoint hotels in yellow. Greenpoint's a great neighborhood where I enjoy leading tours, but it's at the northern tip of Brooklyn. If you're focused on Greenpoint, fine, but the two main hotels (not the Franklin Guesthouse) are a good walk from the subway and somewhat far from the prime shopping and restaurants (though that zone is expanding). Greenpoint even gives you access to nearby Long Island City in Queens.

Also note three Bedford-Stuyvesant hotels in the center of the map. Two, marked in gray, are along busy, noisy Atlantic Avenue, and are less expensive hotels. Bed-Stuy shopping, restaurants and tree-lined streets are within walking distance, but not immediately nearby. The Akwaaba Mansion, on the other hand, is a lovely real bed-and-breakfast on a prime block, so a good location for visitors focused on Bed-Stuy.

I've marked, in black, two hotels worth a cautious assessment. I'm not saying they're bad hotels, but their location is remote, so they're best for people who have reasons to be nearby.

Of course, different budgets mean different choices. The Holiday Inn in Downtown Brooklyn will be more expensive, and offer more amenities, than the Holiday Inn Express in Gowanus (labeled, confusingly, New York-Brooklyn) or the Holiday Inn Express in Sunset Park. The Gowanus location, if/when it's no longer serving as a shelter, is a far better location than Sunset Park.

A note on AirBnB: there are fewer such locations available, but, beyond obvious questions about price and quality, they come with the same significant questions about location, including proximity to transit and shopping, as well as--unlike with most hotels--sometimes issues of safety.

The map below is a screenshot from a larger interactive map from The CITY, a nonprofit news website. Most of Brooklyn, as with New York City, is blue (Democratic), but a not insignificant, and growing share is red (Republican), or at least redder.

What areas vote Republican? Well, notably enclaves of Orthodox Jews, including three Hasidic neighborhoods and a large Modern Orthodox area, which are culturally conservative.

Also, Brooklyn's Chinese communities and "Russian" (former Soviet Union) communities, as well as some of what would be called "white ethnic" (notably Italian-American) areas.

Many neighborhoods, including ones that voted for Democratic nominee Kamala Harris, appear somewhat less blue, as shown in this map suggesting a shift toward Republican candidate, and now President-elect, Donald Trump. Some of that was less an increase in Republican votes than Democratic voters staying home, as this NY Focus article explains.

People moving to Brooklyn often want advice on safety: which neighborhoods, or parts of neighborhoods, are safer()?

The answer: it's tricky, because gun violence, for example, is more prevalent late at night, and among people--notably gang members or wannabes--who know each other. And it's also somewhat more prevalent near public housing complexes, though most residents try to live decent lives on limited incomes and 42% of households work.
 
That said, a May 2024 New York Times interactive feature on gun violence shows some sharply divergent results for Brooklyn, including clusters of violence and areas with few shootings.

Those clusters include, on my annotated map below, public housing complexes in Fort Greene/Downtown Brooklyn (pink--purple arrow) and in Red Hook (light blue arrow), in the western part of the borough.

Turning toward Central Brooklyn, the south central part of Bedford-Stuyvesant (dark blue arrow) and the western part of Crown Heights (dark purple arrow), also have a somewhat elevated record of shootings, even as those neighborhood gentrify steadily.

Finally, the darker-red highlights on the map indicate neighborhoods with concentrations of poverty and violence, notably southeast Crown Heights and Brownsville. There's a deeper story here about the lingering effects of inequitable development in Brooklyn, told notably in Craig Steven Wilder's A Covenant with Color: Race and Social Power in Brooklyn.​

You might be wondering what I think of the recent "36 Hours in Brooklyn" travel section feature, which the New York Times published June 6, or its two predecessors, published in 2011 and 2017.

The answer: they're all useful, but need to be seen as guidelines rather than prescriptions. In 2017, I critiqued that year's incarnation for unwise broad generalizations  but my biggest quibble concerned the pursuit of breadth over depth. If you followed the 2017 advice, you'd traipse through DUMBO and go to the Brooklyn Roasting Company but not the chocolate shop Jacques Torres, which is a neighborhood gem and does have coffee.

I recommended a more concentrated effort to get more out of your surroundings.

This year's version
The most recent feature is somewhat better, but still suffers from trying to do too much. The article scants the amount of time, effort, and money--public transit, bike, car service--it takes to get between neighborhoods and in some cases offers unwise sequences.

Let's take a closer look. "This itinerary skips the most touristy and overdeveloped areas, including Williamsburg and Dumbo, and requires no restaurant reservations or advance planning," writes Ingrid K. Williams.

OK, but one of the restaurants recommended, Untable in Carroll Gardens, is tiny and already very hard to get into. (I've only been for lunch.) Why not offer an alternative?

If you're new to Brooklyn, it's still worth visiting Williamsburg--not every part is touristy--especially if, as the article suggests, you should start your Saturday in Greenpoint. The neighborhoods are adjacent. I always recommend tackling Brooklyn neighborhoods in clusters. You could easily spend the whole day in Greenpoint and Williamsburg.

Why just visit a bakery, a coffee shop, and Transmitter Park in Greenpoint? I lead walking tours of 2.5 hours--sometimes far longer--in Greenpoint, because there's so much more to see.

Logistics, logistics

Wait a sec, though: if you're doing this itinerary on a Saturday, as recommended, the G train--the only subway to Greenpoint--won't stop there from June 28 through Aug. 12. If your next stop is Fort Greene, as recommended, after Greenpoint, the G train won't be stopping there between Aug. 12 and Sept. 3.

Let's pretend the G train is working. Rather than take the recommended route--Greenpoint to Fort Greene to Clinton Hill to Bedford-Stuyvesant, before going to the Brooklyn Museum--someone attempting this unwise breakneck pace should rather get out first in Bed-Stuy, which is the closest to Greenpoint, then Clinton Hill, then Fort Greene.

Bed-Stuy's a huge neighborhood. The article suggests a first stop at the bookstore Word is Change, then the nearby boutique Byas & Leon. OK. Then "refuel a few blocks away at A&A Bake Doubles and Roti," which, unmentioned, is a 9-minute walk. Then it's a 13-minute walk (unmentioned) to BLK MKT Vintage, and an 8-minute walk to Black Star Vinyl. The final stop, Fan-Fan Doughnuts, is--unmentioned--a 27-minute walk! 

But there's so much more to see in Bed-Stuy. Fan Fan is relatively close to the Pratt Institute in Clinton Hill: a 12-minute walk. Then there's far more to see in Clinton Hill--wide streets and mansions--before exploring eclectic Fort Greene.

Whether you take the Times's advice or mine, it's still a ridiculous plan. Carve out more time for the Brooklyn Museum, the adjacent Brooklyn Botanic Garden, and the adjacent neighborhoods of Prospect Heights, Crown Heights, and Flatbush.

Stick around the area for dinner instead of trying to get to Bushwick for dinner, which Google suggests is a 37-minute trip from the museum, at least if you catch the 3 train--which comes every 12 minutes--in a timely manner. Hey, the best way to Bushwick, on the L train, is from... Williamsburg.

The bottom line

Brooklyn needs more than 36 hours and bears repeat visits. If you only have a little time, think adjacencies.

​I just checked the reader comments on the article, and the second-most popular one--after a nice anecdote--stated, "Lots of great spots featured but this itinerary is a bit ridiculous and has you hopping around in all kinds of directions and doubling back and forth between general sections of BK."

Amen.

The Brooklyn Bridge is pretty glorious, right? It's a marvel and an icon.

Truth be told, I never loved leading a "Brooklyn Bridge tour" because, given crowds, walking the bridge can be a frustrating experience for all but small groups.

Recently, though, I've concluded that it's not enough to walk the bridge and tell the story of the bridge.

It's crucial to see the bridge from various angles in both Manhattan (photo below) and Brooklyn, and to look at the art and photography it has inspired. So I've revised and renamed my tour as Viewing (and Walking) Brooklyn Bridge, and More in Brooklyn and Manhattan. It's particularly nice at sunset, or at dawn, as seen in the photos below.

People sometimes ask me: what books are good preparation for a trip to Brooklyn?

The answer: there's no single definitive volume of non-fiction, much less fiction. And some books are centered in particular neighborhoods.

Here's are a couple of preliminary lists, which I will update.

NON-FICTION
Fodor's Brooklyn. Dated but somewhat useful neighborhood guidebook. Out of print; available used.
Brooklyn: The Once and Future City, Thomas Campanella. Great tales of less-heralded Brooklyn, but ends before the present day.
The Invention of Brownstone Brooklyn. Suleiman Osman. Wonky but fascinating history of gentrification.
The Great Bridge, David McCullough. The definitive history of the Brooklyn Bridge.
A Covenant with Color: Race and Social Power in Brooklyn, Craig Steven Wilder. A definitive--as of its 2001 publication date--study of inequitable development. Could use an update.
The Boys of Summer, Roger Kahn. On the Brooklyn Dodgers.
When Brooklyn Was the World, 1920-1957, Elliot Willensky. The best on nostalgia.
An Architectural Guidebook to Brooklyn, Francis Morrone. Great on neighborhoods, but 2001 publication date means it could use an update, especially regarding Downtown Brooklyn.
The New Brooklyn: What It Takes to Bring a City Back, Kay Hymowitz. A useful but incomplete (and sometimes contestable) account of Brooklyn's recent fate and future.
Coney Island Lost and Found, by Charles Denson. The best history of Coney, also slightly dated.
A Walker in the City, Alfred Kazin. Working-class Jewish striving, from Brownsville.
The Brooklyn Wars. Neil deMause. Some recent contestations in the borough.

FICTION (past)
A Tree Grows in Brooklyn, Betty Smith. An unlucky but plucky girl in Williamsburg, early 1900s.
The Chosen, Chaim Potok. 1940s Williamsburg, Modern Orthodox and Hasidic Jews.
Brown Girl, Brownstones, Paule Marshall. Barbadian family in Bed-Stuy, in the 1950s.

FICTION (more recent)
The Fortress of Solitude, Jonathan Lethem. Gentrification's early days, when Gowanus became Boerum Hill.
Pineapple Street, Jenny Jackson. Rich people problems in Brooklyn Heights.
Brooklyn, Colm Toibin. An Irish immigrant young woman in the 1950s.
Another Brooklyn, Jacqueline Woodson. Black Bushwick in the 1970s.
Dreamland, Kevin Baker. Old Coney Island, a very unusual place.
Prospect Park West, Amy Sohn. Not-quite-rich people problems in Park Slope.

What’s right, and wrong, with those “Top Ten” or “Top 20” lists of things to do or visit in Brooklyn?

Quick here’s one from TripAdvisor, another from Time Out New York, another from U.S. News and from two other websites.

Well, for people new to Brooklyn, they can be helpful summaries that clarify what many think are worthwhile activities.

(There are also some oddballs in there. The Royal Palms Shuffleboard Bar & Club is a fine—and unique—place to visit, but I wouldn’t put in a Top 20 list. But I'm no longer young. Similarly,  Brooklyn Crab in Red Hook is worth a visit, but it shouldn’t be the only thing on your Red Hook list. Yes, I lead tours there.)

DIY or with a guide?

All these attractions indeed can be visited on your own, without a tour guide. However, a tour can add far more context, historical photos, and fine-grained insight to neighborhoods like DUMBO, Brooklyn Heights, Park Slope, and Williamsburg.

A tour guide can help on the Brooklyn Bridge, but it’s so crowded it may not be worth it, so I don't push my services.

Even a place like Coney Island, where the iconic boardwalk is free, with views of (in-season) rollercoasters like the Cyclone and Thunderbolt, plus the Wonder Wheel, deserves a deeper understanding.

Fitting things in

The lists also include locations of vastly different sizes. The Brooklyn Heights Promenade (on my Brooklyn 101/202 tours, as well as Brooklyn Heights & DUMBO), is smaller than Brooklyn Bridge Park, which is far smaller than Prospect Park.

Moreover, any list is not geographically conceived, so people new to Brooklyn don’t know how different attractions related to each other.

I always recommend that people aim to visit neighborhoods that are adjacent or—sometimes more complicated to newbies—within easy connection by subway or bus. If you book me for a tour, I can make recommendations, but here's a start.

Clusters of culture

So if you’re visiting Prospect Park, that’s when to also consider the Brooklyn Museum, the Brooklyn Botanic Garden, and the Brooklyn Public Library’s Central Library, all clustered around Grand Army Plaza, which is the park’s northwest gateway.

For those choosing my Brooklyn 101 or Brooklyn 202 tours, which include a stop at the library (if it’s open), we can start or end near the museum, so it’s possible to visit the museum and the garden. (Note: my tours go into the park, but I leave others to lead comprehensive tours of the park.)

The New York Transit Museum, which is not near Prospect Park, is a less-known gem, so I’m glad it’s on some lists. It’s close to Brooklyn Heights, Downtown Brooklyn, and Cobble Hill/Carroll Gardens, so it can be a springboard to my tours. 

The Brooklyn Academy of Music is central to another cultural cluster in Fort Greene, including three BAM buildings, a theater, and smaller cultural spaces. We can easily start or end near there.

Food and drink

The Brooklyn Brewery and Kings County Distillery are fine places to visit, but there are so many microbreweries in Brooklyn that it’s a shame to limit yourself. In fact, it would make sense to organize a geographic “crawl,” given clusters of breweries in Gowanus, Red Hook, and Bushwick. (Williamsburg, home to the Brooklyn Brewery, does have another craft brewery, Ebbs, in walking distance.)

Many sources recommend the weekend food fest Smorgasburg, which is indeed worth a visit (in Williamsburg and Prospect Park, in-season) for convenience and creativity, though don’t expect great bargains.

Two indoor food halls, Time Out NY Market (in DUMBO) and DeKalb Market (in Downtown Brooklyn), are also worth visiting and can be incorporated into my tours, either within the tour, or at the end.

Some lists recommend organized food tours. If food and convenience are your priority, fine, but if you want to see more things, it’s typically possible to incorporate food into a more comprehensive neighborhood tour.

Taking the ferry

The East River Ferry indeed is a top attraction, given the views of Manhattan, Brooklyn, and Queens, but I’d recommend it most as a connection between DUMBO and Williamsburg, Greenpoint, or (in Queens) Long Island City, all worth significant exploration.

Shopping

Some recommend the Brooklyn Flea, which is in DUMBO in season and spawned the even-more-popular Smorgasburg. It’s worth visiting—and can be incorporated into a tour—but is hardly the only source for shopping.

Similarly, L Train Vintage in Bushwick is fine, but, honestly, if you want to thrift, it’s probably wiser to walk the East Village.

Larger contexts

Industry City, recommended for both shopping and eating, is a worthwhile destination, but is best seen in the larger context of the nearby Sunset Park neighborhood.

Similarly, if you just want to see street art, go to the Bushwick Collective (and/or take someone else's tour), but if you want to see some of the art in the larger neighborhood context, take my Bushwick tour.

Sure, Domino Park in Williamsburg is worth a visit, but again I'd suggest within the larger context of the neighborhood.

I recently got a tour request from a couple of seniors (from a Midwestern state in the USA) who are contemplating their first visit to New York City, bringing their 12-year-old granddaughter. They're thinking about hiring a guide for two to four hours a day over three to four days to introduce them to NYC.

That's not actually in my wheelhouse--blame the name of my company!--but it's fine that they contacted me.

Below is a modified version of my response. 

If you look at my website, I actually do not specialize in introductory NYC highlights (Financial District, Times Square, Central Park, etc.) but rather on more focused walks around various neighborhoods, mostly in Brooklyn, and a few in Manhattan and Queens.

In other words, they're generally for people who've already seen those highlights and want to go beyond. I suspect you'd probably want to spend at least two, maybe three (maybe all?) days in Manhattan.

Please keep in mind that NYC is large—you can't see a lot in two hours, even if you're limited to Manhattan.

There are numerous guides who could help you in Manhattan, as well as scheduled group tours.

(I can​ lead tours in Manhattan—I did a 9-hour tour a few weeks ago that included pieces of Manhattan, Brooklyn, and Queens—but others specialize in Manhattan.)

Some DIY research

I'd encourage you to first buy (or borrow from the library) a guidebook, so you can figure out your priorities. In other words, you generally don't need a guide to take you around a museum.

I'd also encourage you to join the Facebook group What to Do in NY and search​ for people reporting on what they did with a 12-year-old.

Two helpful Facebook groups for visitors include New York City Tourist Help and New York City Tourist Tips.

Also think about how much walking you can do, and whether you'd want to cut down on distance by taking public transit (buses or subway) or taxis.

Finding and paying a guide

Think about your budget for a private guide: it will cost you minimum $60-$75/hour, and some guides do charge $100+/hour.

If you can't find a guide recommended in Facebook or other web searches, you can always search on the Guides Association of NYC website. Or post a request for a guide (the more focused the better).

What about Brooklyn?

Finally, if you would​ like a tour of Brooklyn with me after you do the highlights in Manhattan, we could do an introductory tour: Brooklyn Bridge, DUMBO, Brooklyn Heights, etc. My fees are here (but will go up slightly in 2024),

Why specialize?

As noted above, I can lead introductory tours in Manhattan and did combine part of one with a larger tour that included Brooklyn and Queens. That was for a recurring client--a leader who brings 5-6 different people to New York once a year for a full day of touring!

But I don't market myself for those tours because I don't specialize in those highlights. Sure, I can show you Times Square and Rockefeller Center and part of Central Park, and it will be "good enough" for new visitors. But I know some other guides are there all the time and know all the nuances.

I spend a lot of time trying to keep with the complexities of all the neighborhoods (mostly Brooklyn, plus two in Manhattan and three in Queens) where I do lead tours.

That said, if anyone does want a tour that combines boroughs with Manhattan, that could work. I'm happy to lead more long tours!

You might be surprised to learn that New York City does not have official neighborhood boundaries, and some new names have emerged as the product of re-branding by neighborhood boosters and/or real-estate agents. Here an interesting article in the New York Times about the contested boundaries.

Note, in the screenshot at left, the boundary zones where the colors aren't solid.

History lessons
​
For example, once upon a time there was an undifferentiated area of "South Brooklyn," which referred not to the southern sections of today's Brooklyn, like Coney Island or Bay Ridge, but to the southern part of the old City of Brooklyn, established in 1834, while the rest of Kings County--today co-terminous with Brooklyn--was unincorporated.

By the 1960s or so, in an effort to distinguish row-house sections of South Brooklyn from nearby--but separated by a highway--Red Hook, a maritime industrial neighborhood with a massive public housing complex, those boosters conceived of Carroll Gardens and Cobble Hill. There are unusually deep front gardens in Carroll Gardens, though the only hill in Cobble Hill is historical. But it sounds more posh.

New questions

Today, the debates more concern the effort to expand, or contract, a border. Consider: the border of Prospect Heights, long thought of as Washington Avenue, is no longer fixed, as real estate listings a block or two east of Washington now claim Prospect Heights rather than Crown Heights. See the yellow-to-green section in the bottom right of the screenshot.

The logic is that these more upscale apartments have more in common with most of Prospect Heights than much of Crown Heights, which has more working-class blocks, many with rent-stabilized units, to the east. Then again, Crown Heights also has its own historic blocks.

You want to understand Brooklyn?

Well, consider this quote from a store owner, relayed by photographers James & Karla Murray, who have been on a mission to capture disappearing storefronts in the city. Katy's Candy Store was at 125 Tompkins Avenue in Bedford-Stuyvesant. That's hardly the gentrified section of Bed-Stuy, but rent for that space is now much higher.

Note: I tend to speak that third language when I cross the street and encounter dangerous drivers and ebike riders.

I haven't yet gotten to visit the Brooklyn Botanic Garden (and we're members!) in recent weeks, but Green-Wood Cemetery, which is within walking distance for me and where I just led a tour yesterday, offers some glorious spring flora, including azaleas, tulips, dogwoods, cherry blossoms (not shown--too late), and even a weeping beech tunnel. 

So the flora are a bonus, on top of the cemetery's fascinating history, rolling hills, impressive statuary, great views, and feeling of repose--achieved within a not-long walk from the busy city. 

The screenshot below, from an interactive map produced by The Trace regarding gun violence in America since 2014, is pretty stunning.

The red dots indicate fatal shootings; the yellow dots non-fatal ones. The shootings are disproportionately clustered in certain neighborhoods, including Brownsville, East New York, Bedford-Stuyvesant, Crown Heights, and Flatbush.

A closer look shows that specific blocks--in many cases near public housing projects--are more dangerous than others. But what the map doesn't show, at least as of now, is the time of shootings. A good number are surely late at night.

Little more than three years after its April 2009 founding, the crowdfunding site Kickstarter, basking in rapid growth and a $10 million boost from venture capital investors, agreed to spend $7.5 million to buy and renovate part of the landmarked Eberhard Faber pencil factory complex in Greenpoint.
 
“We are hoping to stay at 58 Kent [Street] forever — to be our permanent headquarters,” Kickstarter CEO Perry Chen told Community Board 1, according to the New York Post. (Image at right, pre-renovation, from 2007 NYC Landmarks Preservation Commission report.)
 
The Landmarks Preservation Commission hailed the adaptive re-use design by architect Ole Sondresen, with Scott Henson, which remodeled the remains of three connected 19th century factory buildings, which had been demolished above the second floor in the 20th century, and combined three facades, which had two truck bays installed.
 
Upon the revamped building’s opening, Kickstarter and its then-80 employees held a block party, closing off Kent Street to demonstrate some projects supported by the platform, and offering tours of their workspace. (Below image from current B6 listing.)

“Kickstarter's New Office Is Incredible,” pronounced Business Insider in May 2014, citing the building’s inner courtyard, garden, and library. 
 
Indeed, the adaptation included a new one-story rooftop addition, an interior glass courtyard, and new windows, with Corten steel perimeter framing, which replaced a bricked-up facade.  The building offered not just office space but also a library, kitchen, gallery, and theater, using significant amounts of reclaimed wood.
​
Just before the pandemic hit, in February 2020, Kickstarter employees voted to form a union, after a history of contention. (Below image from current B6 listing.)

Layoffs and closing
 
Three months later, Kickstarter announced that the COVID downturn in fundraising forced it to lay off 25 workers. The Verge reported that the total, including buyouts, was 30 people, out of nearly 140 staff; the union cited the severance package it negotiated.
 
As work-from-home became the norm, and 58 Kent was mercilessly tagged by graffiti vandals, Kickstarter in 2021 decided to become a fully remote company. 

​Last April, Kickstarter, then with nearly 100 employees, announced it was joining several other firms testing a 32-hour, four-day workweek and this January said it was making the Monday-through-Thursday schedule permanent. (Below photo Dec. 2, 2021, by Norman Oder)​

Chief Strategy Officer Jon Leland told Benefit News that the policy was helping with recruitment and retention. That pivot supplants the old strategy—offering a purpose-built headquarters in an atmospheric North Brooklyn neighborhood.

Building for sale

​Today, 58 Kent is being marketed by B6 Real Estate Advisors as a “custom-built flagship office building,” containing 30,000 square feet of space, half a block from Franklin Street, “one of Greenpoint's most desirable retail corridors.”

Citing the “exceptional natural light provided by a central, glassed-in courtyard garden,” B6 says the “property redefines the concept of going to the office, with open-air worktables, private offices, glass meeting rooms, a 2,500 square foot library, a 74-seat theater, an open-air commercial kitchen, diner-style kitchen seating, tiered wooden bleachers, and a glass penthouse” that leads to a “lushly landscaped” rooftop garden.

Still, Brooklyn office space had a 17.8% vacancy rate, as of the fourth quarter of 2022, according to Newmark, and the landmarked Domino Sugar building in Williamsburg is being transformed into a 460,000 square foot office building, without an anchor tenant.

So, mindful of that challenging market, B6 notes that “the property and zoning would permit conversion to an event venue, retail, gallery, or showroom, or virtually any other commercial use."

And if the building sells anywhere near the asking price, it might represent a tidy profit for Kickstarter (even if the renovation costs exceeded the original budget), little more than a decade—and a world-changing pandemic—after the company’s stated aspiration of “forever.”

In posts like How Not to Write a "Neighborhood Guide to Brooklyn," I've noted misguided efforts, in travel publications, to somehow propose a one-day visit to disparate parts of a vast, city-like borough.

Well, it gets worse. I just saw A Stroll Through Brooklyn: The Ultimate Guide for a Memorable Trip, which somehow describes Brooklyn as "an ever-evolving neighborhood with plenty to see and do" and then lists the following highlights: the Brooklyn Bridge, Prospect Park, the Brooklyn Museum, the Brooklyn Flea (seasonally closed, actually), and "some local cuisine."

The latter two examples are DiFara Pizza, which is not located near any of the above, and Miss Lily's, which is in Manhattan.

Oh well. The site, upon further inspection is called StupidDope, and it's apparently a content mill to draw eyeballs to a (not legal, though not prosecuted) cannabis delivery service.